As I mentioned in a previous post, we have moved to northern Idaho. It snows here. Even though it is spring, and the sun doesn't go down until after eight, it still snows. A light-hearted, "Welcome to Idaho" sort of snow.
Me: Hey, kids. Look. It is snowing outside.
Sam: I don’t see any snow.
Jonah: It’s like a blizzard out there.
Catie: If it is snowing, I probably better skip my nap.
The reality? It was snowing. It was not a blizzard. And, in no way was it relevant to Catherine’s nap. This left me wondering. Why are my kids so weird?
Having given it some thought, I can now announce that my children aren’t (always, completely) weird. They’re just very different from each other. Let me explain.
Sam’s Snow
Sam is very literal. He knows what he knows, and if you want him
to know anything more, you need to teach it to him.
He understands cause and effect, but he does not extrapolate new
information. And, Sam’s only experience
with snow is what he has seen on television. On TV, “snow” is an object, a
noun. Mounds of noun-snow heaped up
everywhere. Noun-snow hills for
sledding. Noun-snow snowballs. Noun-snow snowmen. When I said it was snowing, Sam looked
outside, at the ground. He saw no
accumulation of snow, therefore, it was not snowing.
Jonah’s Snow
Jonah is more imaginative. He sees nuances. And, is a wee bit melodramatic. Unlike his brother, he has firsthand
experience with the “stuff” that is snow, but still very little experience with
“snowing.” Verb-snow. He knows verb-rain. So, when Jonah looked
out the window, he expected to see snow falling like rain; down. What he saw was light, fluffy snow swirling
around in the wind. When rain does that
we call it a hurricane. When snow does
that, Jonah calls it a blizzard. This is
reasonable. (Especially when you go back and read the part about being a wee
bit melodramatic).
Catie’s Snow
Catie is a four year old girl with
only one care in the world. Herself. Her
experience with snow is also limited, but irrelevant. She didn’t even look out the window. She sensed a disturbance among her subjects and
immediately tried to work it to her advantage.
She took a nap anyway.
There is an old anthropological
study that says in the Eskimo languages there are 50 words for snow. Add three more.
That was lovely...a keeper for your children when they are older.
ReplyDeleteYou should see the pictures of Eastern US today! Sam would give it the noun-snow approval!
Hmmm... Who am I most like? Maybe Catie. And a little of Sam. Hmmm... Maybe we need to add my word(s) too. I'll have to think about it.
ReplyDelete